Rationality Freiburg

Plans & Surprises

Start: Friday, March 27, 2026 6:00 pm
End: Friday, March 27, 2026 8:30 pm
Location: Veranstaltungsraum, Haus des Engagements, Rehlingstraße 9, 79100 Freiburg (Map, Coordinates: 47.98953, 7.83979)
Host(s): Omar
Type of event: exercise, discussion
This event on meetup.com
This event on lesswrong.com

Preparation

If possible, bring a laptop to the meetup. Don’t worry if you can’t, since you’ll spend most of the time thinking and discussing as opposed to playing. We can take turns.

What will we do?

Humans often solve complex problems via iteration and empiricism. Usually, trying to figure everything out from first principles without experimenting is a bad idea. You can spend loads of time thinking, and then you go outside and interact with reality for 5 minutes and realize all that thinking was pointed in the wrong direction.

But some important problems have poor feedback loops, such that iteration/empiricism don’t work very well. Experimentation might take a really long time, the results might be noisy, or you might just really need to get something right on the first try.

Often, when making a plan in a confusing domain, it’s enough to just ask yourself “how do I expect this plan to turn out?” to get you to notice ways the plan is likely to fail. Then you can fix those things. This is often faster than doing the entire plan, and watching it fail, and then doing it all over again.

In this exercise, we will use a puzzle video game to practice a combination of rationality skills:

  • Planmaking — formulating a complete plan before acting
  • Calibration — assessing how confident you are in each step
  • Inner Sim / Surprise-o-meter — noticing when something feels off
  • Patience — resisting the urge to just start fiddling

These skills weave together into something similar to Murphyjitsu, but with a somewhat different flavor.

Format

  1. You’ll be given a puzzle video game level, which you haven’t played before.
  2. Instead of fiddling around, playing with the game the way you might normally do… you will just look at the screen, and make a complete plan for solving a given level, before you begin to move your character around.
  3. Write down that plan as a series of steps.
  4. Before you execute your plan, for each step in the plan, consider all the ways that you might be surprised when you execute that step.
  5. Loop through all of your “possible surprises”, and consider if any of them actually seem more likely than your mainline plan. Consider updating your plan. If there is a step that might go multiple ways, try making multiple guesses and plans.
  6. Are you confident in your plan? If so, execute it.
  7. Did the plan go the way you expected? Spend 10 minutes reflecting on what you learned, and what you could have done differently.

Organization

You are worried you have nothing to contribute? No worries! Everyone is welcome!

There always is a mix of German and English speakers and we configure the discussion rounds so that everyone feels comfortable participating. The primary language is English.

This meetup will be hosted by Omar.

There will be snacks and drinks.

We will go and get dinner after the meetup. Anyone who has time is welcome to join.

Location (Veranstaltungsraum, Haus des Engagements)

In the above map the location where you should leave your bikes is marked in blue and the entrance (at the end of the metal ramp) with a red cross.

Other

Learn more about us.

A person studying a puzzle, planning their moves carefully

Image generated with Gemini / Nano Banana.